Forscan Lite vs OBD Link apps - first impressions
Posted: Thu Jan 18, 2018 11:47 am
So I got my OBDLink MX Bluetooth dongle for Christmas ( but only arrived a couple of days ago ) and been playing with a couple of the Android apps, (OBDLink and Forscan Lite.)
Here are my impressions so far. If I have got any glaring errors feel free to correct.
OBDLink App
Pros
- It is FREE, but only works with the genuine Scantool branded OBDLink MX dongles.
-Nice in the way it connects and works seamlessly with the OBDLink dongle ( because it is designed to work with it I guess)
-Very configurable dashboard in terms of colours, size etc of the dials. Nice and easy to set up.
-Lots of options for display features. The HUD ( Head Up Display ) mode looks promising, need to check that out some more.
- can do OBDLink MX dongle firmware updates directly from the app. ( need to have wifi or 4G connectivity on the same phone of course ). App will also warn you when an update is available.
Cons
- does not seem to report DTC fault codes off all the modules. Forscan Lite reported a couple of BCM fault codes that OBD Link did not.
- any Ford unique PIDS have to be entered and configured manually in order to monitor them (e.g trans fluid temp, battery state of charge ). Although thanks to Stewart we do have the config, details for the most important ones.
Forscan Lite
Pros
- Designed specifically for Ford vehicles, so detects and reads all the Ranger modules. ( same as the full PC version of Forscan ).
- All the PIDs are available to select, no need to configure manually. I very easily set it up to read the things that I wanted ( Trans Fluid Temp, Battery Voltage, Battery Current, Battery State of Charge, Vehicle Speed, Engine Coolant Temp ) without having to enter any Hex codes etc. Just need to find and select the right PID from the "All" modules menu. ( Hint: the search function comes in very handy here )
- Picks up DTC fault codes from all modules. ( not sure how important it is, but there were three to do with aircon and the headlights that the OBDLink app not show, which I cleared and have not come back )
Cons
- Costs money for the full version ( about $5.95 ). There is a free demo app you can download to check compatibility with your devices but it is restricted to reading one PID from each module only.
-Not as "pretty" as the OBDLink app, quite basic dials and gauges and no changing of colours etc. For example, you can't make one dial larger than the others like on OBDLink.
- cannot do firmware updates from this app.
- no way to enter user defined PIDs as with OBDLink and Torque Pro ( although not sure why you would need to )
- it is a bit fiddlier to get started after the ignition has been turned off. You have to push the "Play" button every time to get data flowing again. Whereas OBDLink I think it does that automatically.
So I think for me the best solution is to have both on the phone to get full useability. I have a Galaxy S5 phone that has been retired from daily use, but works perfectly with both these apps, so it will become a dedicated OBD reader.
Be interested to hear others impressions of these, maybe add some more pros and cons of each.
Here are my impressions so far. If I have got any glaring errors feel free to correct.
OBDLink App
Pros
- It is FREE, but only works with the genuine Scantool branded OBDLink MX dongles.
-Nice in the way it connects and works seamlessly with the OBDLink dongle ( because it is designed to work with it I guess)
-Very configurable dashboard in terms of colours, size etc of the dials. Nice and easy to set up.
-Lots of options for display features. The HUD ( Head Up Display ) mode looks promising, need to check that out some more.
- can do OBDLink MX dongle firmware updates directly from the app. ( need to have wifi or 4G connectivity on the same phone of course ). App will also warn you when an update is available.
Cons
- does not seem to report DTC fault codes off all the modules. Forscan Lite reported a couple of BCM fault codes that OBD Link did not.
- any Ford unique PIDS have to be entered and configured manually in order to monitor them (e.g trans fluid temp, battery state of charge ). Although thanks to Stewart we do have the config, details for the most important ones.
Forscan Lite
Pros
- Designed specifically for Ford vehicles, so detects and reads all the Ranger modules. ( same as the full PC version of Forscan ).
- All the PIDs are available to select, no need to configure manually. I very easily set it up to read the things that I wanted ( Trans Fluid Temp, Battery Voltage, Battery Current, Battery State of Charge, Vehicle Speed, Engine Coolant Temp ) without having to enter any Hex codes etc. Just need to find and select the right PID from the "All" modules menu. ( Hint: the search function comes in very handy here )
- Picks up DTC fault codes from all modules. ( not sure how important it is, but there were three to do with aircon and the headlights that the OBDLink app not show, which I cleared and have not come back )
Cons
- Costs money for the full version ( about $5.95 ). There is a free demo app you can download to check compatibility with your devices but it is restricted to reading one PID from each module only.
-Not as "pretty" as the OBDLink app, quite basic dials and gauges and no changing of colours etc. For example, you can't make one dial larger than the others like on OBDLink.
- cannot do firmware updates from this app.
- no way to enter user defined PIDs as with OBDLink and Torque Pro ( although not sure why you would need to )
- it is a bit fiddlier to get started after the ignition has been turned off. You have to push the "Play" button every time to get data flowing again. Whereas OBDLink I think it does that automatically.
So I think for me the best solution is to have both on the phone to get full useability. I have a Galaxy S5 phone that has been retired from daily use, but works perfectly with both these apps, so it will become a dedicated OBD reader.
Be interested to hear others impressions of these, maybe add some more pros and cons of each.